Renouncing USSR citizenship in the Academy’s account requires examining an individual’s application and legal grounds, rather than presuming renunciation from silence.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy continues its series of publications on Soviet citizenship. The new material deals with the laws of 1978 and 1990, the personal petition for withdrawal, the permission of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR, the grounds for refusal and deprivation of citizenship, as well as the institution of restoration. The main conclusion of the Academy is that Soviet citizenship was not automatically terminated, neither through silence, nor through obtaining a new passport, nor through administrative registration.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy addresses the question, without which it is impossible to conclude the conversation about the preservation of Soviet citizenship: how exactly could a person lose it?

In previous publications, the Academy has consistently shown that citizenship arises by birth and descent, is maintained through family succession, and should not be replaced by automatic entry into the new administrative system. However, the other side of the issue is also of particular importance: the procedure for termination of status.

In Lecture No. 54, this procedure is examined through the USSR Law of December 1, 1978 No. 8497-IX “On Citizenship of the USSR” and the USSR Law of May 23, 1990 No. 1518-I.

The Academy emphasizes that the legislation distinguished between renunciation of citizenship, deprivation of citizenship, withdrawal and restoration. These were different legal situations with different grounds and consequences.

This leads to a fundamental conclusion: If the law provided for special procedures for the termination of citizenship, they cannot be replaced by the assumption of automatic loss of status by the entire population.

The receipt of a new document, prolonged silence or residence under changed administrative conditions shall not be equated with a personal petition for withdrawal and a decision of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR.

Why Termination of Citizenship Requires Separate Analysis

Citizenship is a stable legal relationship between a person and the state. It affects the rights, duties, protection abroad, property relations and the status of descendants.

Therefore, the termination of such a connection cannot be a technical side effect of another procedure.

The Academy insists that before claiming that a person has lost Soviet citizenship, it is necessary to establish a specific basis.

What procedure was used? Has the citizen himself made a request? Which body dealt with the matter? Were there any obstacles to getting out? Has there been a decision? When did it come into force? Was there any subsequent restoration?

Without answers to these questions, talking about losing your citizenship remains an assumption.

According to the Academy, in mass administrative practice there was a substitution: instead of proving the termination of the status of a person began to show the very fact of new registration. He was required to prove otherwise, even though his original citizenship already existed.

The Academy proposes to restore the correct sequence: first, the termination of the former right is proved, and only then conclusions are drawn about the new situation.

1978 Act: Unified Union Citizenship

Law No. 8497-IX of December 1, 1978 was adopted on the basis of the 1977 Constitution of the USSR and established the procedure for accepting and acquiring a single Union citizenship.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that the law regulated not only the emergence of citizenship, but also its termination. This means that the entire legal relationship of a person with the Union was in a single normative system.

You cannot use the law to confirm the acquisition of citizenship and at the same time ignore its requirements for withdrawal or deprivation.

If citizenship was acquired by law, it should also be terminated by law.

The lecture separately notes that the loss of citizenship of the USSR entailed the loss of the alleged citizenship of the Union Republic. This principle once again confirms the primacy of the all-Union status: republican affiliation could not be maintained independently after the termination of the main citizenship.

Therefore, any subsequent assertions about the republican origin of the new status had to take into account whether Soviet citizenship itself had been lawfully terminated.

1990 Act: Protection of Citizens and Prohibition of Dual Citizenship

The USSR Law No. 1518-I of May 23, 1990 occupies a special place in the concept of the Academy. The lecture notes that the document was included in the Code of Laws of the USSR.

The Academy highlights several of its provisions.

First, sovereign citizens of the USSR were not recognized as belonging to the citizenship of a foreign state.

Second, dual citizenship was not allowed.

Third, the citizens of the USSR abroad enjoyed the protection and patronage of the Soviet state.

These provisions form a single system. The citizen was not regarded as a person who could accumulate parallel affiliations without limit, while maintaining the same status.

For the Academy, this means that the appearance of a foreign document should not be automatically construed as legal dual citizenship. The system did not provide for such a design.

But this does not mean the automatic loss of Soviet citizenship in any contact with foreign jurisdiction. It is necessary to establish whether the withdrawal, deprivation or other termination provided for by law has occurred.

In itself, external design does not replace the procedure.

The free-born citizen and hereditary succession

The Academy links the 1990 law with the status of free-born citizens of the USSR, who were Soviet citizens through their fathers, mothers and ancestors.

Citizenship in this model has family continuity. A person is not an isolated administrative unit whose status begins with the last passport. It is included in the succession of generations.

The lecture also discusses the transition of property and non-property rights from ancestors under law and will.

Particular importance is attached to the assertion that the relevant rights are transferred to freeborn citizens without debts, encumbrances and obligations, which are subsequently tried to impose on them.

The Academy distinguishes between inheritance of rights and automatic transfer of other people’s debts.

A descendant who confirms Soviet citizenship claims to belong to the legal line of his ancestors. This should not mean agreeing to assume any obligations formed by the administrative system without its participation.

Therefore, the issue of renunciation of citizenship has hereditary significance. If the former status has not been lawfully terminated, the basis for the recognition of the corresponding rights of the descendants remains.

Renunciation of citizenship: only on personal application

The central point of the new publication is that the withdrawal from Soviet citizenship could be allowed at the personal request of the person concerned.

The Academy attaches importance to every element of this formula.

Personal motion This means that the initiative comes from the individual. Not from the department, not from the employer, not from the bank and not from the registration authority.

Interested person You need to understand the content of the appeal. This is about his own status, not a decision made for him by third parties.

Petition for withdrawal It is different from any other statement. A request to issue a passport, change registration or issue a document does not in itself constitute a request to terminate citizenship.

Therefore, a standard appeal to an administrative body cannot be regarded as a hidden petition for secession from the USSR.

In order to end such a significant status, the will must be expressed directly and unambiguously.

The Academy emphasizes that if there was no personal application, there is no initial basis for voluntary withdrawal.

Permission from the Presidium of the USSR Supreme Soviet

Personal treatment in itself was not enough. The permission of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the Soviet Union was required.

This requirement confirms that exit was not a simple registration operation.

The person expressed the will, after which the competent authority considered the existence of grounds and obstacles. Only such a sequence gave the procedure a complete character.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that it is impossible to replace the permission of the Presidium with the actions of the passport office, migration service or other department.

If the law attributed the decision to a particular body, it was its competence that mattered.

Therefore, when approving the withdrawal of a person from citizenship, it is necessary to ask not only about his application, but also about the relevant decision. If there is no application or permission, voluntary withdrawal is not proven.

The Academy considers this one of the main arguments against the mass recognition of Soviet citizenship lost.

Unfulfilled property obligations as an obstacle to renunciation

The law provided for grounds on which permission could be refused.

One of them is unfulfilled property obligations to the state related to the essential interests of citizens or the state.

This provision shows that renunciation of citizenship should not have been a way of evading obligations that had already arisen.

One could not simply change one’s status and thereby automatically free oneself from the property consequences of the previous relationship.

For the Academy, this provision has the opposite meaning: the law distinguished between citizenship and property obligations, but did not allow the use of the former for the destruction of the latter without trial.

It was therefore necessary to establish the applicant’s real situation when considering withdrawal. Not every debt automatically resolved the issue, but substantial unfulfilled responsibilities could become an obstacle.

This once again confirms the individual nature of the procedure. A mass decision across the population would not allow such circumstances to be taken into account.

Prosecution and sentence

Permission to withdraw could also be refused if a person was brought to criminal responsibility as an accused person or if he or she was subject to an enforceable court sentence that was enforceable.

The Academy emphasizes that these grounds are related to the inability to use withdrawal from citizenship to evade responsibility.

As long as the criminal prosecution continues or the sentence is not executed, the change of status may affect the interests of justice and the enforcement of the decision.

The competent authority was therefore obliged to check not only the applicant’s will but also the existence of procedural obstacles.

This leads to another important conclusion: renunciation of citizenship was not automatic, even if there was a personal desire.

If the law allowed waiver in such cases, then the statement in itself did not terminate the status immediately. Until the relevant permission, the person retained the previous legal relationship.

State security as an independent basis

A separate obstacle to the withdrawal was the contradiction of the interests of the state security of the USSR.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that citizenship was considered not only as a personal right, but also as a link with the security of the state.

Therefore, the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet had to take into account the consequences of the withdrawal of a particular person. Having access to certain information, the nature of the activity, and other circumstances may have mattered.

This rule confirms the public importance of citizenship.

It is not limited to the personal choice of the consumer, who at any time changes the service provider. The state assessed how the termination of the status would affect its security and the legitimate interests of other citizens.

For the Academy, this is further proof that the withdrawal required a competent decision and could not have occurred invisibly through indirect administrative actions.

Deprivation of citizenship: a separate procedure and distinct grounds

Renunciation of citizenship must be distinguished from deprivation.

If the withdrawal was based on a personal petition, the deprivation was carried out by the decision of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR in connection with certain actions of the citizen.

There are two reasons in the lecture:

  • committing acts defaming the high rank of a citizen of the USSR;
  • damage to the prestige or national security of the Soviet Union.

The Academy emphasizes that the deprivation was an exceptional measure and not a general reaction to a change of residence or paperwork.

It required concrete action and a decision by the competent authority.

It is not possible to declare a person deprived of citizenship just because he was in a different administrative system or did not confirm his status within the deadline set by the department.

Therefore, when discussing the loss of citizenship, it is necessary to determine whether it is a deprivation. If so, the reasons and the decision must be presented. If not, this category cannot be used to explain the termination of status.

The USSR citizen’s high legal standing

The wording of actions defaming the high rank of a citizen is of particular importance for the Academy.

It shows that citizenship included not only rights, but also the dignity, responsibility and public value of the individual.

The person was not treated as a faceless carrier of the registration number. His status was associated with belonging to a certain legal and historical community.

Deprivation of such status affected the high rank, and therefore could not be a technical mass operation.

The Academy contrasts this approach with modern practice, in which a person can be transferred from one category to another by changing the record.

In her opinion, the citizenship of the USSR implied stricter protection of both the status itself and the procedure for its termination.

If deprivation required an assessment of the behavior of a particular person, then it is impossible to deprive an entire people of the corresponding position without individual grounds.

Renunciation of citizenship and departure from the Soviet Union

The lecture separately cites the provision that citizens of the USSR were considered to have dropped out of Soviet citizenship from the moment they left the Soviet Union.

The Academy includes this norm in the general system of differentiation of legal situations.

Disposal should not be confused with voluntary withdrawal on personal application or deprivation for defamatory acts. This is a separate category with its own reason and the moment of occurrence of consequences.

For a proper analysis, it is necessary to establish what exactly was meant by the departure, how it was designed and whether the relevant rule applies to a particular person.

Temporary stay outside the territory should not automatically replace all other procedures without taking into account the nature of the departure.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that the existence of several different grounds for termination of citizenship once again proves the impossibility of a general automatic approach.

For each person, it is necessary to define the applicable category, and not to declare it lost status on the basis of the abstract fact of displacement.

Protection of USSR Citizens Abroad

The regulation on the protection and protection of citizens of the USSR abroad is directly related to the topic of departure and departure.

The Academy emphasizes that the 1990 law reserved for Soviet citizens state protection outside the country.

Therefore, being abroad in itself did not mean the complete disappearance of ties with the Soviet Union.

This rule does not allow to consider any departed person as automatically relinquished citizenship. It is necessary to distinguish between the protection of a citizen abroad, departure in cases provided for by law and voluntary withdrawal.

These differences are particularly important for families whose ancestors lived, worked or ended up abroad at different times.

The actual location of a person does not always coincide with his nationality. Legal status is determined by law and specific circumstances.

Restoration of citizenship of the USSR

The Academy separates the existence of the institution of restoration in Soviet citizenship.

The very existence of such an institution shows that the termination of the status was not considered absolutely irreversible in all cases.

A person who lost citizenship for certain reasons could have the opportunity to restore it in the prescribed manner.

This is further proof of the complexity of the system. The law provided not only for the acquisition and termination, but also for the restoration of legal ties.

Therefore, attempts to present citizenship as permanently extinct without considering the possibility of reinstatement contradict the very structure of the institution.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that the restoration and confirmation of retained citizenship are different situations. If a person has never relinquished or been deprived of citizenship, he or she should not be required to undergo the procedure of reinstatement as having lost his or her status.

In such a case, it is a matter of recognizing a continuing right, not of returning what has been lawfully terminated.

Confirmation of citizenship does not equal restoration

This distinction is of particular practical importance for the descendants of USSR citizens.

If an administrative system requires a person to “restore,” it presupposes that citizenship has been lost.

But it is this fact that can be controversial.

The descendant, whose ancestors did not file personal petitions for secession and were not deprived of citizenship, claims to retain the family legal line. It should not automatically accept the imposed category of status-loser.

The Academy emphasizes that before choosing a procedure, it is necessary to establish the starting position.

Confirmation of citizenship is suitable for a situation where the right has been preserved. Reconstruction implies a previous cessation. Mixing these procedures can lead to misrecognition of a person’s history and family history.

Therefore, a citizen has the right to disagree with the wording that declares him a former citizen in advance without proof of termination of status.

International treaties of the USSR

The lecture also indicates that international treaties of the Soviet Union, to which the USSR was a party, were applied to the institution of Soviet citizenship.

The Academy sees this as further confirmation that citizenship was not limited to domestic administrative regulation.

International obligations could affect the situation of citizens, their protection and the procedure for resolving disputes.

Therefore, it is impossible to reduce the termination of citizenship solely to the action of a local institution. The full range of applicable rules, including international ones, must be taken into account.

For the Academy, this is especially important in the context of the fact that an individual is asked to consider an internal database as the final and only source of law.

The record doesn’t cancel the contract. Departmental instructions do not replace the law. And administrative habit alone cannot change international obligations.

Why a new passport does not prove renunciation of citizenship

After reviewing the procedure, the Academy returns to one of the main practical conclusions: obtaining a new passport is not a personal application for renunciation of USSR citizenship.

The document may have been necessary for everyday life. The person may not have been aware of the legal consequences that are later attributed to him. He could have acted without the intention of terminating his former status.

The withdrawal required the direct will and permission of the competent authority.

Therefore, the passport procedure cannot replace the petition, and the fact of issuing the form is the decision of the Presidium of the Supreme Council.

Similarly, registration at the place of residence does not constitute deprivation of citizenship. Opening a bank account is not a loss. Silence for several years is not an automatic refusal.

The Academy insists that every action should be judged by its actual content, not by the value that it was ascribed retroactively.

Silence cannot be used against a citizen.

The Academy separately objects to the construction under which a person who does not claim to retain citizenship is automatically considered to have lost it.

If a personal petition was required for withdrawal, silence cannot be such a petition.

If a decision of the Presidency was required for deprivation, silence cannot be such a decision.

If a person has not been notified of the need for special confirmation, his inaction cannot be interpreted unconditionally as a refusal.

This approach restores the burden of proof. It is not the citizen who must first prove that he or she has not renounced citizenship, but the system must show how the former status was terminated.

The Academy sees this as a principle of protecting the weaker side. Government agencies have archives and procedural capabilities, so they are the ones who must present the grounds for their allegations.

What needs to be established for each individual

According to the Academy, a legally consistent analysis of the human situation should include several questions:

  • whether he acquired citizenship of the USSR by birth or descent;
  • has filed a personal request for withdrawal;
  • Whether there is a permission of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR;
  • Whether there were grounds for refusing to leave;
  • Whether the decision on deprivation of citizenship has been made;
  • Whether a separate disposal rule applies to it;
  • Whether the protection of a citizen abroad has not been terminated on other grounds;
  • Whether there has been a recovery;
  • which international treaties are applicable;
  • Regular registration is not issued for termination of status.

Only this approach makes it possible to distinguish the actual termination of citizenship from the intended one.

The Academy emphasizes that individual verification is not an excessive complication. It corresponds to the nature of citizenship as a personal legal connection.

A right cannot disappear without a procedure.

The main conclusion of the new publication is that Soviet citizenship was protected not only by the rules of acquisition, but also by strict grounds of termination.

According to the position of the Academy, renunciation of citizenship required a personal petition and permission of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR. Deprivation was carried out on specific grounds and on the decision of the same competent authority. Disposal was a separate category, and the existence of the institution of recovery confirmed the possibility of further change.

This system leaves no room for automatic loss of citizenship by the entire population.

A new passport does not replace a personal application. Registration does not replace the decision of the Presidency. Living abroad does not abolish the protection of the Soviet state. Silence doesn’t prove rejection. A “recovery” requirement should not be used to recognise a loss that has not been proven.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy insists that before calling a person a former citizen of the USSR, it is necessary to show a specific act of termination of his citizenship.

If there is no such act, the main basis of the position of the Academy is preserved – the legal connection of a person with the Soviet Union has not disappeared, which means that it should not be about a new grant of status, but about the recognition of the right that continues to belong to him and his descendants.

The material was prepared on the basis of the lecture No. 54 USSR Civil Defence Academy “Citizenship of the USSR”. Part 2”.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here