Resolution No. 467 in the Academy’s interpretation: remote assessments, disability and legal capacity, with attention to the distinctions between these concepts.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy continues a series of publications on the hidden mechanisms of changing the civil status. The new material considers the Government Decree of April 9, 2020 No. 467 “On the Temporary Procedure for Recognizing a Person as a Disabled Person”. According to the position of the Academy, the temporary procedure could be used for absentee examination of the population, the formation of electronic databases and the subsequent recognition of citizens with limited rights without their written consent.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy refers to the Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation of April 9, 2020 No. 467, which formally concerned the temporary procedure for recognizing a person as a disabled person.

In Lecture No. 54, this document is considered not as an isolated measure in the field of medical and social expertise, but as part of a broader system of electronic documentation of the population.

According to the position of the Academy, the temporary and externally technical order concealed the possibility of changing the status of a person in absentia. A medical or social record could have consequences far beyond the scope of care: in electronic records, a person was associated with disability, incapacity, the need for guardianship and restriction of independent rights.

The Academy emphasizes that this is not about humiliating people with disabilities or denying their right to medical and social support. The subject of the research is the inadmissibility of using the medical category for the concealed deprivation of a person’s independent legal will.

The state of health itself should not make a person an object of disposition. But it is this use of electronic records that the Academy puts at the center of its analysis.

Why the interim ruling caught the attention of the Academy

Documents that are accepted as temporary are often perceived by society as less important. It is assumed that they operate for a limited period, solve a narrow practical problem and are not able to significantly change the long-term situation of a person.

The Academy warns against this simplification.

A time order can create records that are retained after the end of the period itself. The electronic database, formed in exceptional conditions, is able to continue to be used in new procedures and influence decisions about a person without re-referring to him.

Therefore, it is not enough to know that it was temporary in order to evaluate the decision No. 467. It is necessary to establish what information was formed, where it was transferred, what legal conclusions were drawn from them and how long these conclusions were preserved.

The Academy believes that it is the long-term use of temporary data that poses the main danger.

A person may not even know about the creation of the record, but subsequent structures will perceive it as the basis for decisions about their rights, payments and legal capacity.

Assessment without attendance or written consent

The central statement of the lecture is that the decree allowed the examination to be conducted in absentia and without the written consent of the citizen.

The Academy sees this as a fundamental change in the relationship between the individual and the expert system.

When applying directly, a person understands what procedure is being carried out, what documents he submits and for what purpose. They can ask questions, agree or disagree, and get a decision.

Distance model can violate this transparency. If a person does not participate in the procedure and does not know about it, he is deprived of the opportunity to check the initial data, dispute the error and understand the consequences of the conclusion.

In the opinion of the Academy, it is especially unacceptable to give such a procedure a mass character.

The individual need for a remote solution should not become a basis for circular or per capita assignment of status to entire categories of the population. Health and ability to work relate to a specific person and cannot be determined from a common list without a proper basis.

The Academy insists that the lack of written consent is of particular importance if the record is subsequently used not only for medical care but also for legally relevant findings.

How a medical record turns into a restriction of rights

In the concept of the Academy, Resolution No. 467 was used for the electronic recognition of citizens by persons who have lost legal capacity, legal capacity and delicacy.

There is a transition between different levels.

The first level is a medical or medical-social conclusion. It is associated with health, functional limitations, and the need for support.

The second level is social status. It determines the right to payments, rehabilitation and other measures.

The third level is civil law. Here we are talking about the ability of a person to independently perform legally significant actions, express will and be responsible for their decisions.

It is the automatic transition from the first two levels to the third that creates the greatest danger.

If an electronic medical record begins to be used as evidence of a person’s general inability to act, a person may be deprived of an independent voice without a separate and understandable trial.

The Academy emphasizes that no database should automatically replace the individual establishment of legal status. The presence of disability, disease or the need for rehabilitation does not give grounds to consider the entire population of the corresponding category incapacitated.

Electronic, circular and per-capita records

The lecture uses three characteristics of the application of the decree: electronic, circular and per capita recognition of citizens.

The electronic form means that the status is fixed in a digital database and can be automatically transferred between systems.

The circular form involves the application of a general decision to a group of people according to a single rule, without a separate substantive analysis of each case.

Per capita accounting links the record to each person on the list, while maintaining a general mechanism for assigning status.

The Academy considers the combination of these forms as a mechanism for massive changes in the legal status of the population.

When a decision is made according to a common algorithm, the person ceases to be a participant in the procedure. He becomes a line in the list, and his individual circumstances do not affect the result.

Of particular concern is the possibility of further automatic use of such data. Even if the initial entry was created for social support, other systems may read it as evidence of limited legal capacity or the need for custody.

Thus, one technical status begins to work in areas for which it was not originally intended.

Large electronic datasets and their use abroad

The Academy separately points out that the formed electronic records acquired the value of big data and could be used abroad to confirm a certain situation of the population.

In its concept, it is not just about storing medical information. Joint databases allow to form a general characteristic of whole groups: able-bodied, disabled, independent, in need of care and subject to relocation or rehabilitation.

Such aggregated data can be used for decisions that are made outside of direct human contact.

The Academy draws attention to the dangers of international or external use of records without understanding their origin. If the correspondence procedure was controversial, then the transfer of its results to another system does not make the original data more reliable.

On the contrary, scaling a record increases the consequences of an error.

A person may face a situation where their status is challenged not by one institution but by several interconnected bases, each referring to another. The original foundation remains hidden.

Therefore, the Academy requires to evaluate not only the content of the decree, but also the entire chain of movement of the generated data.

Settlement colonies and recording the population as having departed

One of the hardest blocks of the lecture is related to the statement about the use of records to recognize citizens as settlers and confirm their departure in the settlement colony.

The Academy sees this design as a continuation of the previously described refugee-settler model.

If a person is recognized as disabled, in need of treatment and rehabilitation, a special accommodation regime may be assigned to him. In the hidden interpretation of the Academy, this regime enshrines him not as an independent citizen, but as a person under external control.

Further, the corresponding record can be used to confirm the departure of a person from the previous civil registration.

This is a fundamental point: a change in the place or mode of stay becomes the basis for exclusion from the register of legal entities.

The Academy emphasizes that social assistance should not be accompanied by the loss of civic identity. Referral to treatment or rehabilitation cannot automatically mean withdrawal from the people, renunciation of property rights or termination of status.

If such consequences are secretly recorded, it is no longer a matter of care, but of redistribution of rights.

Exclusion from registers of legal entities

According to the position of the Academy, the ultimate goal of such a system was to exclude people from civil registers and registers of legal entities.

Such an exception has a property value.

A person who is not recognized as an independent entity cannot fully declare claims, dispose of assets and participate in the restoration of their rights. Other structures begin to act for him, and he himself receives only the minimum security provided for him.

The Academy formulates this as a transfer from the position of the creditor or the bearer of the right to the position of the recipient of limited assistance.

If a person had rights to funds, income, annuities, or hereditary interests, a change in status could prevent the person from making a claim.

A design emerges in which assets continue to exist, but the former entity is no longer recognized as having the right to claim them.

For the Academy, this is a key motive for the hidden appropriation of incapacity: not to change the medical characteristics, but to change the legal ability of a person to participate in the distribution of rights and property.

Soviet funds, trusts and social payments

In the lecture, Decree No. 467 is associated with an attempt to seize Soviet funds and financial resources in the world banking system, including income and annuities from church international trusts and foundations of the USSR.

The Academy considers the replacement of such rights with minimum social and insurance benefits as an unequal substitute.

A person who has an independent property claim is in the same legal position. The recipient of the benefit or insurance payment is in another.

In the first case, he claims to be his rightful owner. In the second, it receives support in the amount and manner prescribed by the administrative system.

The Academy emphasizes the distinction between a pension and a minimum social or insurance payment to a settler.

If a person is offered a minimum security instead of recognizing his or her property rights, this can create an external picture of social protection while concealing the original claims.

According to the Academy, the issue is not only the amount of payments. It concerns the basis: whether a person receives a part of his own funds and income or he is granted a benefit as a person deprived of independent property status.

Absence of State Registration of Resolution

The principal counter-argument of the Academy is the assertion that there is no state registration of Resolution No. 467.

The competent authorities of the Soviet Union recorded this circumstance and notified international regulators and supervisors.

According to the position of the Academy, the absence of registration means that the decree is an invalid act and cannot serve as a basis for legally significant changes in the status of a person.

This argument is consistent with the general methodology of the Academy: the presence of a published text and the actual application of the procedure do not replace the necessary steps for giving the act legal force.

If the document has not passed the required registration, the records created on its basis should not be automatically recognized as flawless.

The Academy emphasizes that the invalidity of the base must also affect derivative actions. It is impossible to invalidate the decision, but to continue to apply all the statuses formed by it as final.

A medical and social assessment must not replace the individual’s will

The Academy reports that international regulators have been notified of the nullity of the use of the examination under Decree No. 467 to perform legally significant and titular acts for a person.

This thesis has an independent significance.

Even if a medical procedure has been performed, the result should not automatically confer on third parties the right to dispose of the status, property and titles of a citizen.

The medical report answers questions within its competence. It is not a universal permission to act for a person.

The Academy believes that it is the illegal extension of the meaning of an assessment that poses the main threat. A medical or expert record can be used to prescribe help, but its transformation into a basis for the concealed alienation of rights is unacceptable.

A person should not learn about the limitation of his own will after the fact – through a refusal in a transaction, a change in payments or the actions of a representative whom he did not authorize.

Why 2020 is called a period of distraction

In the lecture, the implementation of the decree is associated with the events of 2020 and public discussion of changes to the Constitution.

The Academy sees this coincidence as a distraction: the public’s attention was focused on a large-scale public discussion, while electronic procedures that could affect personal status remained on the periphery of attention.

This thesis explains why a significant proportion of people may not have noticed the practical significance of the document.

The society discusses general political formulations, but does not receive a clear explanation of what bases are formed, what conclusions are drawn in absentia, and how these conclusions will be used.

For the Academy, this is a typical mechanism of hidden transformation: the most significant changes occur not in loud slogans, but in technical procedures that seem secondary to the population.

Therefore, the 2020 Interim Ordinance requires the same scrutiny as documents directly devoted to citizenship.

The USSR’s claimed guardianship of Soviet citizens since 1945

A separate block of the lecture is devoted to guardianship and guardianship.

The Academy claims that the Soviet Union since 1945 established custody and guardianship over Soviet citizens and did not recognize the rights of the Roman pontiff, cardinals and other external persons to patronage over them.

In the concept of the Academy, this means that the issue of the protection of a citizen already had its own legal framework and could not be transferred to an external structure without a proper basis.

Guardianship in this sense should not mean enslavement or alienation of rights. It is regarded as protection in the interests of the individual and does not negate his sovereign dignity.

The Academy contrasts this model with external care, in which a person is deprived of independence, and his property interests begin to represent other persons.

Therefore, the reference to 1945 is used to justify the inadmissibility of imposed patronage. A Soviet citizen should not automatically become the object of someone else’s guardianship just because the electronic system has assigned him the appropriate category.

Why assistance must not be conflated with loss of independence

The new publication of the Academy has an important moral and legal result: care for a person should not become the basis for his erasure as a subject.

Medical care, rehabilitation, social support and protection of interests are necessary. But their purpose is to support a person, not to abolish his will.

If a person needs help, this does not give him the right to be considered property, expelled from civil society or deprived of hereditary claims.

The Academy emphasizes that the fight against hidden misappropriation of disability should not turn into a denial of the real needs of people with disabilities. On the contrary, respect for them requires the same recognition of dignity and autonomy that the Academy seeks for all citizens.

Inadmissible is not medical examination as such, but its hidden use for purposes about which the person did not know and to which he did not consent.

What a citizen should know about their electronic status

The position of the Academy suggests the need for a more transparent attitude to electronic records.

A person should understand what information about him was formed, by what act it was done, whether his consent was present and what bodies received the data.

It is especially important to distinguish between medical diagnosis, social category and civil status. This information should not be combined into one automatic characteristic without separate legal grounds.

If the record is used to act for a person, it is necessary to establish who received such authority, on what basis and to what extent.

The Academy believes that a citizen should not prove his independence just because an anonymous database has assigned him a restrictive status. First, the system must prove the legality of the created record.

An act not in force should not create irreversible consequences

The main conclusion of the new publication is that the temporary procedure for recognizing a person as a disabled person should not become a permanent mechanism for restricting rights.

According to the position of the Academy, Resolution No. 467 did not receive the necessary state registration, and absentee and electronic decisions formed on its basis cannot serve as a basis for legally significant actions for a person, his exclusion from the registers of legal entities or alienation of property claims.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy insists that if a document is invalid, it is necessary to check everything derived from it – records, databases, payment decisions, actions of representatives and restrictions on independence.

The original act cannot be declared null and void, but its effects must be preserved as irreversible.

A person should not be held hostage to an electronic mark created without his or her participation. A medical record does not negate dignity. Social assistance does not abolish citizenship. Custody does not mean the right to dispose of a person as property. A temporary procedure should not permanently determine its place in the legal field.

According to the Academy, the restoration of justice begins with a simple principle: A living person is more important than any base, and his will and rights cannot be extinguished by a decision in absentia.

The material was prepared on the basis of the lecture No. 54 USSR Civil Defence Academy “Citizenship of the USSR”. Part 2”.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here