Law No. 62-FZ of 2002 in the Academy’s interpretation: citizenship, registration and property rights, and why it distinguishes documents from individual legal status.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy continues a series of publications on the origin of Russian citizenship. The new material deals with the law of May 31, 2002 No. 62-FZ “On citizenship of the Russian Federation”. The Academy claims a violation of the rules of its adoption and the timing of publication, and also discloses the hidden, in its assessment, content of the law: the transfer of citizens of the USSR to the status of migrants and the transfer of public property in trust management for fifteen years.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy refers to one of the main documents of modern citizenship legislation – Federal Law No. 62-FZ of May 31, 2002.

It is this law that is associated in public opinion with the final design of the institution of Russian citizenship. However, the Academy proposes not to accept its legal force as self-evident and not to start the analysis with the usual assertion that the document automatically determined the status of the entire population.

Lecture No. 54 called the law No. 62-FZ false and invalid. The Academy points to two independent grounds: violation of the rules of acceptance and the absence of publication in the official press within the period prescribed by law.

In addition to procedural violations, the study deals with the content of the document. According to the Academy, the law did not ensure the recognition of USSR citizens as full-fledged subjects of Russian citizenship, but created conditions for their transfer to the category of foreigners, migrants and persons in need of external guardianship.

Thus, the issue of the 2002 law is not limited to the verification of details. It concerns the very content of the status that has been conferred on millions of people.

Why does the 2002 law require a separate review?

In previous publications, the Academy has reviewed the 1991 RSFSR Act, the 1993 amendments, and subsequent Population Documentation Acts. The 2002 law occupies a special place in this chain.

It is perceived as a new regulatory framework, after which the previous disputes about citizenship are considered completed. But the Academy stresses that a later law cannot automatically eliminate defects in previous acts if its own procedure is also flawed.

It is impossible to prove the legitimacy of the whole system by simply referring to its most recent document.

Therefore, the Academy proposes to consistently check:

  • how the law was enacted;
  • Whether the regulations were followed;
  • when and where it was published;
  • What status did it establish?
  • How did it relate to the retained citizenship of the USSR?
  • What property consequences were associated with its use.

Only then can you assess whether the document has created a full citizenship or fixed a different registration model.

A breach of procedural rules as a defect in the law’s origins

The first argument of the Academy concerns the regulations for the adoption of law No. 62-FZ.

For her, this is not a technical detail of parliamentary work. The Regulations determine how the draft law is considered, which stages are mandatory and under what conditions the text can be considered finally adopted.

If the procedure is violated, the question arises whether the legislature was able to adopt this document in this form.

The Academy consistently holds the idea that the law does not arise at the time of the appearance of a beautifully designed text. He must follow the prescribed path. The name, number and subsequent use cannot retroactively compensate for the violation of the regulations.

The scope of the law’s practical application does not prove its legality. Even if a document is referenced by millions of decisions, it only increases the need to verify its origin.

According to the Academy, the violation of the regulations takes on particular gravity when the law affects citizenship – the basis of a person’s position in the legal system.

Publication within the prescribed time limit

The second argument is related to official publication.

The Academy argues that Law No. 62-FZ was not published in the official press within the time period established by law. Consequently, it could not properly enter into force and be applied as a binding legal act.

Publication does not have a decorative function. It ensures the official communication of the law to society and allows to determine the moment from which citizens should be guided by its provisions.

If the deadline is violated, you cannot automatically consider all the requirements to be met simply because the text has subsequently become known.

The Academy draws attention to the fact that the law on citizenship cannot become effective unnoticed by the citizens themselves. People should be able to know what rules define their status, when they are in effect, and what consequences they have.

Violation of publication therefore affects not only the interests of legislative technology, but also the human right to legal certainty.

Why practical application does not remedy invalidity

The Academy separately objects to the argument that the law’s long-term application confirms its validity.

According to her, the actual application shows only the prevalence of the document, but does not eliminate procedural violations.

If a law is invalid for reasons of adoption or publication, the number of decisions issued on its basis does not make it lawful. On the contrary, the question arises of the fate of all derivative records and acts.

This is especially important for citizens who respond with a reference to the established practice. Practice cannot be the supreme proof of law. It must itself comply with the current law.

Therefore, the Academy proposes not to ask only “whether the law No. 62-FZ was applied”, but to find out “whether it had the right to apply.”

These questions lead to different results. The first is the history of administrative actions. The second checks their legal basis.

Russian citizenship as confirmation of migrant status

Substantial criticism of the law begins with the statement of the Academy that the institution of Russian citizenship in its actual application confirmed not the sovereign affiliation, but the status of a foreigner and a migrant.

In the concept of the lecture, citizens of the USSR were transferred to the category of temporarily residing in the territory of the Soviet Union.

This means that the citizenship document could serve as a residence permit, rather than evidence of a person’s uninterrupted connection to his or her homeland.

The Academy considers such a substitution to be of principle. If a person is born into a family of citizens of the USSR, his or her initial position should not be defined as that of a visitor.

Migrants receive status through the permitting system. His stay is limited by terms, conditions and registration requirements. A free-born citizen, on the other hand, belongs to a legal community of origin.

The transfer of the first to the second without conscious expression of will means a hidden lowering of status.

That is why the Academy does not agree to view the 2002 law as a mere extension of the former citizenship under a new name.

The period until 2017 and acquisitive prescription

In the lecture, the temporary presence of citizens in the Russian status is associated with the period until 2017 and the expiration of the acquisitive prescription period.

The Academy sees the fifteen-year period from 2002 to 2017 as a special regime during which the new registration system was to be anchored through long-term application.

The person used the documents, participated in the procedures and was listed in the records. The system could interpret this as confirmation of his acceptance of the status conferred.

However, the Academy insists that long-term use of the document does not amount to a conscious renunciation of previous citizenship.

Acquisition prescription should not work as a mechanism for the hidden appropriation of rights over the status of a person. If the citizen did not know about the legal significance of the procedure, the mere passage of time cannot replace his will.

Therefore, 2017 is seen not only as the end of a fifteen-year period, but also as a milestone after which the temporary design should be revised.

From now on, the continuation of the old practice requires a new explanation of its grounds.

Refusal to recognize Soviet citizens as Russian citizens

The lecture contains a separate and at first glance paradoxical thesis: according to the law No. 62-FZ, the trading company “Russian Federation” refused to recognize citizens of the USSR as citizens of the Russian Federation.

The Academy explains this refusal not as the release of Soviet people from the new administrative status, but as a basis for the establishment of external guardianship and guardianship over them.

If a person is not recognized as a full-fledged citizen, he can be transferred to an intermediate category: registered, but not independent; included in the account, but not endowed with all rights; obliged to fulfill the requirements, but not authorized to dispose of the common property.

Thus, the denial of citizenship does not necessarily mean the exclusion of an individual from the system. He can remain inside it already as a ward or object of management.

The Academy sees here a mechanism for the withdrawal of sovereign title without the formal disappearance of a person from the registers.

His name remains in the database, the documents remain valid, but the original right is replaced by a limited provision.

Public property in trust management

With the transfer of citizens to a new status, the Academy connects the transfer of public property and property of the Soviet Union to the gratuitous trust management of the trading company “Russian Federation” and the Bank of Russia.

The term of such management in the lecture is defined by fifteen years – from 2002 to 2017.

For the Academy, this is a key property dimension of the citizenship law.

If a citizen of the USSR was considered as a member of public property, a change in his status could affect not only the passport. It determined who was entitled to dispose of the property, receive income and make claims.

The transfer of the population to the position of migrants or wards made it possible to present the governing structures as the only independent participants in property relations.

At the same time, citizens did not disappear physically, but ceased to be recognized as subjects of relevant rights.

The Academy emphasizes the gratuitous nature of the proposed trust management. In her opinion, the transfer of public property should not have taken place covertly, without a clear expression of the will of the people and without preserving their right to demand a report on the results of management.

Trust management does not transfer ownership of the people’s property

The Academy distinguishes between the management of assets and the unconditional acquisition of ownership.

Even if a certain structure was given the authority to administer the property, it should not automatically mean that the people lost all property rights.

The trustee acts within the established limits and bears duties to those in whose interests the management is carried out.

However, to realize these responsibilities, it is necessary to know the design itself: the timing, the amount of assets transferred, the sources of income and the reporting procedure.

The Academy claims that the population has not received such an understanding. Citizens saw the change in passports and administrative procedures, but did not see them as the beginning of fifteen years of management of public property.

Therefore, after the end of the term in 2017, in her opinion, the question of the results, the return of rights and the termination of the grounds for further order should have arisen.

The absence of a public report should not mean an automatic extension of management.

Government registration in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities

In the lecture, 2017 is additionally connected with the term of registration of the Government of the Russian Federation as the General Government in the Unified State Register of Legal Entities.

The Academy sees this as part of the corporate governance model.

State power in the usual sense presupposes a public-legal mandate. Registration in the register of legal entities emphasizes the organizational and corporate form of the existence of the structure.

For the Academy, this is another argument in favor of the need to distinguish between the state as a legal community of citizens and a company as a registered subject of accounting.

If a management structure exists in corporate form, its powers should be assessed on the basis of creation, registration and timing. It cannot automatically arrogate unlimited rights over citizens and property.

The completion of the term of registration or trust management, according to the concept of the Academy, requires the termination of the relevant powers or a new legal registration, and not their tacit continuation.

How agencies describe the population after 2017

A special section of the lecture is devoted to the classification of citizens by different departments after 2017.

The Academy argues that the Ministry of Health and the State Statistics Committee consider citizens as “birth products”, including the categories of live births and stillbirths. The Ministry of Education uses the characterization of higher animals with intelligence and consciousness. Courts, services and other bodies treat people as individuals, organisms and objects of law who require guardianship.

The Academy makes these definitions not for the sake of a terminological dispute, but to demonstrate a general direction: a person is consistently transferred from the position of a sovereign subject to the position of a biological or registration object.

Each system chooses its own formula, but the result remains the same. A living citizen disappears as a carrier of an independent will and an object of observation, training, accounting, treatment or guardianship appears.

According to the Academy, this is why a person can face the same treatment in different institutions. It is not listened to as a sovereign applicant, but is treated as a unit of the relevant departmental classification.

The object of law cannot be a full source of power.

The Academy considers the distinction between the subject and the object of law decisive.

The subject is able to have rights, express will, make demands and participate in the formation of obligations. The object is what is being acted upon.

If a person is transferred to the category of an organism or an individual with limited independence, his participation in power becomes formal.

It can vote, sign documents and receive services, but key decisions about its status are made by the system. His own expression of will is recognized only within the limits of pre-supposed procedures.

The Academy sees here the reason why applications for Soviet citizenship can go unanswered. The system does not discuss sovereign status because it treats the applicant in advance as an object of administration.

In order to restore dialogue, first of all, it is necessary to change the initial recognition of the person.

Leaders of the Union Republics in the same system

The Academy extends its criticism not only to the situation of Russian citizens, but also to the status of the leaders of the Union republics.

The lecture argues that their nationality is similarly regarded as belonging to the property of a trading company, not based on national law and not within the jurisdiction of the relevant jurisdictions.

This thesis emphasizes the systemic nature of the problem.

If the status of the head does not have a separate national basis, his authority may be related to the external corporate structure. Then the decisions he makes on behalf of the people require separate scrutiny.

The Academy does not reduce the issue to the personal responsibility of individual leaders. It poses a broader problem: can a person represent a sovereign people if his own legal affiliation is determined by an external system of ownership and accounting?

In her opinion, that is why the restoration of citizenship should take place simultaneously at the level of a person, position and state form.

Why 2017 was the point of no return to the old model

For the Academy, 2017 brings together several processes:

  • expiry of the fifteen-year term from 2002;
  • the end of the period of acquisitive prescription;
  • the end of the term of trust management of the national property;
  • the completion of the period associated with the registration of the Government;
  • Changes in Departmental Methods of Population Classification.

This combination makes the date not just a chronological mark.

The Academy argues that after 2017, the former system could not continue as a matter of course. Required a report on trust management, restoration of rights and revision of status records.

If this does not happen openly, citizens should ask the relevant questions themselves.

In her opinion, the continuation of the use of documents after the expiration of the term does not prove the preservation of the previous powers. This can only indicate the continuation of the actual practice without a re-established legal basis.

Citizenship law should not hide property substitution

The main methodological conclusion of the publication is that the law on citizenship should be read not only as a document on passports.

Citizenship determines the position of a person in the ownership, administration, inheritance and distribution of the common property. Therefore, any change in status has property consequences.

The Academy believes that in the case of Law No. 62-FZ, these consequences were hidden behind the neutral formulation of citizenship.

An administrative act was presented to the population, while the Academy’s concept involved the restructuring of the human condition and the transfer of asset management.

Therefore, the analysis of the document requires answers to the questions:

  • who has become an independent subject of law;
  • Who was transferred to the category of migrants and wards;
  • who received the management of public property;
  • for what period the powers were transferred;
  • What rights are reserved for the citizens of the USSR;
  • What results should have been summed up in 2017?

Without these questions, the conversation about citizenship remains incomplete.

Citizenship should affirm rights rather than abolish them

The main result of the new publication of the Academy is that the law on citizenship can not be used for a hidden lowering of the status of a person.

According to the position of the Academy, Law No. 62-FZ of 2002 was adopted in violation of the regulations and was not published within the deadline. Its application did not create a full-fledged sovereign status for the citizens of the USSR, but fixed the model of a temporary migrant, accompanied by external guardianship and the transfer of public wealth to trust management until 2017.

The USSR Civil Defence Academy insists that the expiration of the fifteen-year period requires a review not only of documents, but also of the entire system of relations between man, governing structures and public property.

A citizen should not become a foreigner on his own land. People shall not be deprived of their property by changing their registration category. And the law on citizenship should not be turned into an instrument for transferring property without the clear will of the people.

According to the Academy, the restoration begins with the recognition of the obvious: a person is a subject of law, not a property of a company, not an object of departmental registration and not a temporary migrant on his own passport.

The material was prepared on the basis of the lecture No. 54 USSR Civil Defence Academy “Citizenship of the USSR”. Part 2”.

Citizenship Law No. 62-FZ: Registration, Status and Property Rights

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here