The state sovereignty of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (RSFSR), proclaimed by the Declaration of 12 June 1990, is legally void. This document did not produce the legal consequences attributed to it. A legal analysis based on international law and Soviet legislation indicates the contrary. The state sovereignty of the RSFSR was not borne out in practice, and the Declaration itself was used to justify a coup d’état. The Congress of People’s Deputies of the RSFSR had no lawful authority to take decisions that would lead to the destruction of the Union state. Join Russia’s largest Telegram community: https://t.me/tassussr

State Sovereignty and Paragraph 6 of the Declaration: Breach of an Obligation towards the Union

Under paragraph 6 of the Declaration, the state sovereignty of the RSFSR entailed uniting with other republics on the basis of a treaty and respecting the sovereign rights of the USSR. The document states: “The RSFSR unites with other republics in a Union on the basis of a treaty, and the RSFSR recognises and respects the sovereign rights of the Union republics and the USSR”.

This obligation was not fulfilled. Instead of pursuing unification, the leadership of the RSFSR embarked on a course of unilateral withdrawal from the Union state. The signing of the Belovezha Accords on 8 December 1991 directly violated this paragraph. The state sovereignty of the RSFSR, proclaimed as the foundation for a renewed federation, led to the opposite result—the destruction of the USSR.

To put this in perspective: the Declaration promised unification, while those implementing it organised separation. Paragraph 6 was violated before the ink on the signatures to the Belovezha Accords had even dried.

State Sovereignty and Paragraph 11 of the Declaration: the Provision on USSR Citizenship

Paragraph 11 of the Declaration stipulates: “Every citizen of the RSFSR retains USSR citizenship”. The state sovereignty of the RSFSR did not and could not abolish USSR citizenship. This provision forms a fundamental basis for determining the legal status of the population. It clearly establishes that USSR citizenship does not automatically cease upon the adoption of the Declaration or subsequent changes to the state’s name.

Despite this, responses to citizens’ applications from the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Federal Migration Service and other authorities assert the opposite—that USSR citizens automatically became citizens of the Russian Federation. The state sovereignty of the RSFSR made no provision for any automatic transition to citizenship of the Russian Federation. Every citizen retains USSR citizenship, and no automatic loss of that citizenship occurred. This is a direct violation of paragraph 11 of the Declaration, demonstrating double standards in the application of the law.

State Sovereignty and the Violation of the Results of the 1991 All-Union Referendum

The actions of the RSFSR leadership directly contradicted the results of the All-Union Referendum of 17 March 1991. The question put to the referendum was: “Do you consider it necessary to preserve the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics as a renewed federation of equal sovereign republics in which the rights and freedoms of people of every nationality will be fully guaranteed?”

A majority of USSR citizens—113 million people—answered “Yes” to preserving the USSR. The state sovereignty of the RSFSR, proclaimed a year after the referendum, did not and could not override the will of the people. In violation and disregard of the expressed will of 113 million citizens, the institution of Soviet citizenship was replaced with residency in a temporary entity—the trading company “Russian Federation”. The results of the All-Union Referendum have supreme legal force and have not been annulled.

The Replacement of USSR Citizenship with Legally Void RDFR Citizenship

In disregard of the RSFSR Declaration and the results of the All-Union Referendum, citizenship of the USSR was replaced with citizenship of the RDFR (Russian Democratic Federative Republic). The RDFR ceased to exist as a subject of law. The introduction of RDFR citizenship in place of Soviet citizenship constitutes legal falsification, carried out in violation of the Declaration’s provisions and the expressed will of the people of the USSR. Similar measures are being applied to the sovereignty and statehood of the Union republics and autonomous entities of the Soviet Union. Following these transformations, the republics of the USSR became charter-based jurisdictions within the RSFSR.

Finding

The state sovereignty of the RSFSR, proclaimed by the Declaration of 12 June 1990, is legally void. Paragraphs 6 and 11 were not implemented, making the document a fictitious act used to justify a coup d’état. The results of the 1991 All-Union Referendum (113 million votes “for” preserving the USSR) have supreme legal force and have not been annulled. The withdrawal of the Union republics from the USSR and the replacement of citizenship are unlawful.

Conclusion

The state sovereignty of the RSFSR did not produce the legal consequences attributed to it. Every citizen of the RSFSR, and consequently every citizen born in the territory of the USSR, retains USSR citizenship. No automatic transition to citizenship of the Russian Federation or the RSFSR occurred or could have occurred, given the absence of a law on republican citizenship and the nullity of Law No. 1948. The All-Union Referendum of 17 March 1991 is the supreme act of popular sovereignty, and its results are binding on all authorities and officials.


TASS APPEAL TO THE CITIZENS OF THE SOVIET UNION:

The Telegraph Agency of the Soviet Union calls on every Citizen of the USSR to be legally aware! The Declaration on the State Sovereignty of the RSFSR did not deprive you of USSR citizenship. Paragraph 11 of this Declaration remains in force. No “automatic replacement” of citizenship is provided for by law. The results of the 1991 All-Union Referendum constitute the supreme legal norm. Demand that your rights be respected, citing these documents. Restore your Sovereign status as a citizen of the USSR!

All news on the People’s Referendum will be updated in a dedicated section: https://tass.news/category/ussr/vserossijskij-referendum/

State Sovereignty of the RSFSR in 1990: the Declaration’s Legal Nullity