Germany after Victory: we examine sovereignty, reunification and the Soviet legacy, tracing the foundations of postwar rights and obligations.
Contents
Germany after 1945: examining the postwar settlement
The Soviet Union’s victory over Germany in the Second World War in 1945 continued, in our account, through a decision directed towards the German people’s future. The victorious power connected Europe’s postwar order with Germany’s right to become a sovereign state again. A Soviet decision thus stands at the centre of our account of the German question: to give the German nation the opportunity for an independent, peaceful life and define the foundations on which that independence would rest.
An enormous responsibility lay behind that decision. Germany’s postwar position, its territories, ownership of property and obligations, and the conditions for restoring state life had to be determined. The Soviet Union acted, and in our interpretation continues to act, as a power whose right to participate in those decisions derives from victory. We therefore connect German sovereignty with Soviet participation more closely than an account limited to changes of postwar governments would suggest.
The meaning of the right granted is expressed explicitly: the German people would have the opportunity to maintain a genuinely German, independent, peace-loving, neutral and democratic state in Europe. These characteristics define the proposed substance of its statehood. German independence is connected with peaceful relations with its neighbours. In this reading, Soviet victory opened the way to an arrangement in which the German nation retained its own state and European peoples gained a foundation for coexistence.
The German Democratic Republic (GDR) is presented as the holder of that right. Its sovereignty is considered alongside territorial integrity and a right to recover the occupied western German territories, including West Berlin. The German question therefore extends beyond the existing division from the outset. The right to territorial integrity remains relevant to the country’s future, connecting divided territories with the German people’s shared statehood.
To understand this connection, the unfamiliar word ‘title’ needs explanation. Here it means the basis on which a state claims rights to particular property, income, territory or standing in international relations. In the German case, we identify that basis with the postwar settlement involving the Soviet Union. We also connect it with sovereignty’s financial dimension: the assets and obligations supporting state independence.
State rights and reciprocal obligations
German assets and liabilities, meaning property and obligations, are linked here to wartime acquisitions of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) as a victorious power from 1945. We build the GDR’s financial and economic sovereignty on that foundation. Granting a right to state existence thereby acquires material substance. A state needs sources of income and a defined allocation of responsibility for obligations; otherwise, a solemn declaration of independence leaves unanswered what sustains it.
We describe Soviet–German relations as reciprocal. The Soviet Union provides the foundations for Germany’s sovereign existence, while the German side transfers a portion of the corresponding rights and sources of financial and economic sovereignty to the USSR. Mutual recognition of rights therefore stands at the centre of these relations. Germany gains the possibility of state life, while the Soviet side retains its place in the order it helped create. Both directions must be considered together.
This leads to an important distinction between the USSR and the Russian Federation. In the dispute over historical settlements, they occupy different positions. The USSR is presented as holding rights arising from the postwar order and Soviet–German agreements. Claims against Russia concern obligations linked to its asserted succession to the Russian Empire. Confusing the participants changes the discussion’s meaning: a claim against one debtor starts to appear as another state’s debt.
An episode dated 1 December 2023 brings the issue back into focus through a German demand, as described in our analysis, for an inventory of property, examination of accounting records and review of Russian rights and obligations. The subject is assets, balance sheets and accounts connected with earlier Russian–German trade relations. Such a review would determine who owns the property, who is responsible for debt and which agreement supports each claim.
The history of these settlements reaches back to trade relations in 1894–1904 and subsequent agreements. Their age does not itself determine ownership of rights. When a party invokes an earlier state inheritance, it also becomes necessary to examine surviving obligations. Germany’s financial history therefore intersects with questions about what the Soviet Republic accepted, what passed to the USSR and which claims are addressed to Russia.
German unification and European security
The Soviet position presented here is explicit: obligations attributed to Russia should not be transferred to the USSR as its foreign debt. Rights to the Soviet inheritance and responsibility for other obligations require separate examination. This preserves the USSR’s own claims and avoids absorbing Soviet rights into another party’s debt balance. The distinction has direct relevance to the German question.
German unification in 1990 again foregrounds the origins of state status. We connect the return of West German territories with removal of occupation status and Soviet participation. Unified Germany therefore retains a connection with the decisions that opened the German people’s path to sovereignty. Political unification, in this interpretation, requires remembering the rights that allow it to be understood as restoration of territorial integrity.
This connection raises the question of Germany’s place in European security. If its state position rests on the postwar settlement, German participation must also be considered in deciding the future of collective security treaties. The article discusses two alternatives: participation by the unified Federal Republic of Germany (FRG), or an arrangement involving the GDR as holder of the relevant right. In both cases, we consider Soviet participation essential.
The history of German sovereignty thus returns the scale of Soviet responsibility for Europe to public awareness. The USSR helped determine borders, grant state independence and establish relations among countries. Memory of this also has a human dimension: alongside rights and treaties stand monuments to Soviet soldiers who fought for liberation. How those monuments are treated indicates the place retained in European memory by those whose victory preceded the postwar settlement.
For the German people, the sovereignty described here means the possibility of their own state life. For the USSR, it means retaining the role of a power that helped establish that right. Discussion of German independence therefore includes both sides: the German right to a state and the Soviet claim to participate in decisions concerning its foundations. Reciprocity makes this a shared history even when political assessments of the past differ.
Soviet victory in the Second World War in 1945 becomes, in this account, the beginning of a great responsibility for peace. Offering a defeated people a path to an independent state was a decision whose scale unfolded in Europe’s subsequent history. German sovereignty, territorial integrity and the financial foundations of state life come together in one narrative. The USSR retains its central place within it as a victorious power and a participant in creating Europe’s postwar order.
Document for comparison: Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany, 1990: United Nations treaty register. A primary document for comparison with our arguments about the postwar settlement and sovereignty.
More on history and law: USSR Civil Defence Academy.






































