The Harvard Project and Soviet property: we trace privatisation, control of resources and the question of who gained from the transfer of shared assets.
Contents
The Harvard Project: tracing political and economic change
A state’s fate is also decided in the economy: who controls resources, who owns enterprises and where the results of collective labour go. These questions frame the account of the weakening of Soviet administration. Behind talk of perestroika, reforms and the end of the Cold War, we identify a sequence of changes affecting property, social life and the country’s independence. Their common subject is the Soviet people’s right to dispose of their own wealth.
This line of argument begins with the postwar world order. In March 1946, Winston Churchill spoke in Fulton, setting out the direction of the confrontation to come. Then, on 12 March 1947, the Truman Doctrine was publicly announced. An economic programme was connected to the foreign-policy objectives of the United States of America (USA). From the Soviet perspective, the confrontation concerned the existence of an independent centre of state power capable of choosing its own path and supporting a different system of social relations.
The Marshall Plan enters the same sequence as a programme for European recovery. Aid, economic reconstruction and the direction of subsequent policy become interconnected. The Soviet position focuses on the price of such dependence: how freely can a state determine its course when the foundations of its economic life are shaped through relations with an external centre of power? The discussion of European recovery thus becomes part of a broader dispute about the postwar order.
In a U.S. National Security Council directive dated by the article to August 1948, the objectives are framed as reducing Moscow’s power and influence and changing its foreign-policy behaviour. Particular significance is attached to bringing the outcomes of peacetime and wartime policy closer together. Pressure is intended to weaken independence even without open armed confrontation. Economic relations become one means of achieving that result.
The characteristics of a future regime are also specified: limited military capabilities, heavy dependence on the outside world, weakened authority over parts of the country and an end to its earlier isolation. A change in political form is linked here to a change in the state’s ability to act independently. For Soviet society, such a shift simultaneously affects security, internal cohesion and the right to determine its own economic priorities.
The subsequent sequence is described through three stages collectively called the ‘Harvard Project’: perestroika, reform and completion. Each has a distinct focus. First, the public’s understanding of the direction of change is reshaped; then governing institutions and the political system are transformed; finally, the changes are to be embedded in ownership and territorial organisation. This sequence connects events that, viewed individually, might have appeared to be independent decisions made in their own time.
Perestroika, reform and ownership
The first five-year period is dated to 1985–1990. Glasnost and the slogan of socialism with a human face accompany preparations for a transition from a socialist to a capitalist order. Mikhail Gorbachev’s January 1987 report on perestroika and the party’s personnel policy is identified as one milestone. The promise of renewal is connected to changes affecting the foundations of the previous system, rather than merely the performance of individual leaders.
For citizens, the meaning of these changes is determined by the fate of collective government. The institutions through which Soviet state life operated lose their former position. People continue living on their own land, but increasingly confront a system in which their participation and rights become unclear. The issue of reform therefore cannot be exhausted by assessing individual political leaders: it is necessary to examine what happens to the position of the people themselves.
The second stage, ‘reform’, covers 1990–1995. Its stated objectives are the elimination of the world socialist system, the Warsaw Pact, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU) and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) itself as a functioning system of administration. Changes to patriotic and socialist consciousness are included in the same sequence. Political institutions and society’s understanding of its own country are to change together, allowing the new order to take root in everyday life.
The renaming of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (RSFSR) on 25 December 1991 is considered within this sequence. Behind the change of name stand questions about who continues to govern, whose rights they represent and how they dispose of the state inheritance. Soviet statehood retains a significance of its own in this account. The loss of governing institutions and a change in administrative form do not remove the question of who owns the common wealth or the people’s right to determine the future order.
The third stage, ‘completion’, is dated to 1996–2000. The emphasis shifts to consolidating change: removing Soviet military structures, transforming the state system and changing the basis of ownership. Such a design requires changes not only to institutions but also to the material conditions of life. This is why the armed forces, state unity, education, healthcare and economic resources appear together.
The elimination of public and state ownership, with private ownership introduced throughout, marks the central property transition. The answer to who owns the results of collective labour changes. At the same time, free education and healthcare are to give way to arrangements in which access to essential goods and services depends on payment. For individuals, reform is experienced through access to education, treatment and the everyday provision for their families.
Resources and social consequences
Economic infrastructure also acquires a new purpose. In the description of the final stage, roads to seaports are connected to the export of the country’s wealth. A new road, by itself, therefore does not answer the question of social benefit. Its significance depends on which flows it serves, where resources are directed and who receives the benefits of their use. Assessing economic development requires attention to this dimension of economic decisions as well.
The scale of the raw-material dimension is expressed through an estimate of annual exports over a fifteen-year period: 57 per cent of oil extracted, 40 per cent of gas, 90 per cent of copper, 97 per cent of nickel and 99 per cent of aluminium. These figures are introduced into the discussion of the direction of resource flows. The principal property question is how exports relate to the country’s interests and the position of the people whose labour created its common wealth.
The Houston Project is presented as a detailed elaboration of the final design. In this account, Russia is to be treated as separate parts, with different forms of external control assigned to them. Siberia, the northwest, the south, the Volga region and the Far East are incorporated into a scheme dividing interests. This describes a proposed dismemberment; its economic meaning is associated with direct access to raw materials and the weakening of unified state administration.
The project’s timetable and the consequences of its implementation are separate questions. The year 2000 is associated with completion of one of the stages described, while 2017 is subsequently identified as the year the projects ended. Yet ending the alleged mechanism does not automatically restore people’s wellbeing. Prices, incomes, pensioners’ circumstances and trust in government continue to shape social life and require informed participation by citizens themselves.
The Soviet response restores the economy’s social purpose. Resources and economic connections should be considered through the lives of the people who worked on their own land and created shared wealth. Defending popular sovereignty therefore includes questions of ownership, the destination of income and access to essential goods and services. State independence acquires material substance through society’s ability to control the results of its own labour.
Understanding this connection opens a path from bewilderment towards informed collective action. Education and lawful cooperation restore people’s ability to discuss the country’s future as a shared undertaking. The Soviet inheritance is connected to their labour, memory and right to shape the organisation of life. Discussion of the end of the Cold War therefore continues through a question that remains central for the people: in whose interests are their resources used, and who is accountable for the consequences of decisions?
Document for comparison: Harvard Project on the Soviet Social System—the Harvard Library collection description. For comparison of terminology, the library describes the project of this name as a collection of interviews with Soviet refugees. This source does not substantiate the article’s account of a plan to transfer ownership.
More articles on history and law: USSR Civil Defence Academy.






































