The USSR State Committee for the State of Emergency (SCSE-USSR), acting through the Extraordinary Constitutional Committee (ECC USSR), has prepared an official explanatory legal opinion addressed to the All-Russian Political Party ‘Union of Communists’ and its leadership. The document was issued in response to the party’s notification letter concerning preparations for an Extraordinary Congress and the proclamation of a so-called ‘state within the red lines’.

The opinion provides a comprehensive legal assessment of the Party’s actions in light of the emergency legislation of the USSR currently in force and the rules of international law. Experts from the ECC under the SCSE-USSR explain in detail the legal status of the highest bodies of Soviet power during the Special Period and point out that the use of USSR state symbols by entities lacking international legal personality is impermissible.

As the document notes, the SCSE-USSR was established in advance as a legitimate emergency body to implement the outcome of the All-Union Referendum of 17 March 1991. Its powers, transferred pursuant to Resolution No. ПВК 035 of the Military and People’s Council of the USSR, dated 24 April 2023, extend throughout the sovereign territory of the Soviet Union and are exercised under wartime laws until the end of the Special Period. In this context, any attempts to establish alternative centres of power, including the proclamation of a ‘state within the red lines’, are regarded as legally void and contrary to the will of the Soviet people.

The opinion pays particular attention to the use of the USSR state flag by the ‘Union of Communists’ party. The ECC USSR emphasises that the flag bearing the hammer and sickle is a sacred symbol of the Great Victory and an exclusive attribute of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. Its use to represent an entity that does not exist in international law is regarded as an impermissible appropriation of state heraldry. Moreover, the document reiterates that the so-called flag of the Russian Federation, approved by Law No. 1-ФКЗ of 25 December 2000, did not undergo the prescribed adoption procedure and therefore has no legal force. Meanwhile, the USSR flag remains the only lawful state flag throughout the territory of the Soviet Union.

The legal analysis also addresses the historical circumstances surrounding the attempted coup in 1991. As the ECC USSR explains, the transfer of powers from the fraudulent USSR President Gorbachev to the self-proclaimed President of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic (RSFSR), Yeltsin, cannot be regarded as an accomplished legal fact, since by the time of this ‘transfer’ Gorbachev had already lost the rights of a lawful head of state. From 19 August 1991, all power passed to the SCSE-USSR, whose decisions have supreme legal force and must be implemented unconditionally.

The opinion particularly emphasises that the 1991 All-Union Referendum on preserving the USSR as a single state retains its supreme legal force and precedence over any subsequent acts, including referendums held in the republics. The results of this expression of the Soviet people’s will remain in effect for as long as there is at least one sovereign citizen of the USSR who wishes to retain that citizenship. This provision, enshrined in the Sovereign Decrees of the USSR Council of People’s Commissars, is the cornerstone of the SCSE-USSR’s legal position.

The ECC USSR also reiterates that the powers of the people’s deputies of the USSR and all bodies elected before 1991 have been suspended in favour of emergency military bodies. Accordingly, the Supreme Soviet of the All-Russian Political Party ‘Union of Communists’, which adopted a resolution establishing a ‘state within the red lines’, acted beyond its powers. Its decisions are deemed void and produce no legal effects unless they are directed towards implementing the outcome of the All-Union Referendum and restoring Soviet power.

Despite its critical remarks, the opinion expresses gratitude to the leadership of the ‘Union of Communists’ party for its active civic engagement and its desire to act within the Soviet legal framework. The SCSE-USSR expresses its readiness to cooperate in bringing the Party’s activities into compliance with emergency legislation and to assist in preparing a lawful Extraordinary Congress, provided that its purpose is to restore constitutional order rather than to create parallel structures.

The full text of the explanatory legal opinion, including a detailed historical and legal analysis of the events of 1991, an examination of the SCSE-USSR’s powers and detailed answers to possible questions, has been published on the official portal. The document is available at the following link: Explanatory Legal Opinion of the ECC under the SCSE-USSR.

The editorial team at tass.news continues to monitor developments and will inform readers of further steps towards restoring constitutional order throughout the sovereign territory of the USSR.