In 1992, the country’s leadership decided against establishing constitutional supervision in the Russian Federation. Instead, the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation was established under the RSFSR Law of 12 July 1991. However, according to a legal analysis, the 1994 Federal Constitutional Law ‘On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation’ was not published in the official press, rendering it void. The 1989 USSR Law on Constitutional Supervision remains in force. Who holds the powers of supervision during a special period, and what is the significance of Constitutional Court Opinion No. 2/3? Read on to find out.

The Refusal to Establish Constitutional Supervision in 1992

In 1992, the country’s leadership took a decision that determined the subsequent development of the system of constitutional justice. Yeltsin refused to establish constitutional supervision in the Russian Federation. This refusal had far-reaching consequences, since a different body was established in place of the constitutional supervision committee envisaged by the logic of the legal system’s development.

The Establishment of the Constitutional Court of the RSFSR under Law No. 1599/1

The new body was created on the basis of a legislative act. The Constitutional Court was established under RSFSR Law No. 1599/1 of 12 July 1991. This law was entitled ‘On the Constitutional Court of the RSFSR’. It is important to note that it was registered as a valid normative legal act in force, meaning that it possessed all the necessary legal attributes at the time of its adoption.

The 1994 Federal Constitutional Law: The Publication Problem

A new Federal Constitutional Law, No. 1-ФКЗ of 21 July 1994, entitled ‘On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation’, was subsequently adopted. However, a fundamental problem arose with this document. This law was not published in the official press. This fact is confirmed by its registration number — Р-199-402-839. In the legal system, official publication is a mandatory condition for a law to enter into force. According to a legal analysis, the absence of proper publication renders this law a void act.

The Continuing Force of the 1989 USSR Law on Constitutional Supervision

Because of the unlawful application of Federal Constitutional Law No. 1-ФКЗ of 1994, which was not published in the official press and is void, a different normative act remains in force in Russia. This is USSR Law No. 973/1 of 23 December 1989. This law is entitled ‘On Constitutional Supervision in the USSR’. Under its provisions, the functions of constitutional supervision are assigned to legislative bodies and Supreme Soviets of People’s Deputies, under which constitutional supervision committees are formed in all Union republics, as well as in autonomous entities.

The Absence of a Constitutional Supervision Committee in the RSFSR

As already noted, no such committee was established in the RSFSR. This creates a conflict of laws, which is resolved as follows. The rights, powers and functions that the republican committee was supposed to exercise belong to the Constitutional Supervision Committee of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. Thus, the Union-level body performs the functions left unfulfilled at the republican level.

The Special Period and the Emergency Powers of the USSR State Committee for the State of Emergency (SCSE-USSR)

An important clarification concerns the conditions under which this legal arrangement operates. In wartime, during a special period and under a state of emergency, the constitutional supervision committee falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the emergency military authorities. The body serving in this capacity is the USSR State Committee for the State of Emergency (SCSE-USSR). This means that, during a special period, the functions of constitutional supervision pass to military structures at Union level.

What the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation Concluded in Opinion No. 2/3 of 21 September 1993

On 21 September 1993, the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation held a hearing at which it examined President Yeltsin’s actions and decisions. Following its examination, the Court issued Opinion No. 2/3. This opinion was entitled ‘On the Compliance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation of the Actions and Decisions of the President of the Russian Federation, Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin’, relating to his decree on phased constitutional reform. The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation found that Yeltsin had violated the Constitution.

Thus, the 1994 Federal Constitutional Law ‘On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation’ is void because it was not officially published. The 1989 USSR Law on Constitutional Supervision remains in force; under that law, the functions of supervision belong to legislative bodies and the Constitutional Supervision Committee of the USSR. During a special period (wartime or a state of emergency), these powers pass to the USSR State Committee for the State of Emergency (SCSE-USSR). Constitutional Court Opinion No. 2/3 of 21 September 1993 found Yeltsin’s actions unconstitutional, rendering all his subsequent acts void. The system of constitutional justice in the Russian Federation, based on the void 1994 law, cannot be regarded as legitimate.

Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation