Foreign citizenship and public service under Law No. 109-FZ: the Academy examines eligibility restrictions, legal status and the documents used to establish it.
The USSR Civil Defence Academy continues a series of publications on citizenship and legal status of officials. The new material deals with the law No. 109-FZ of April 30, 2021 and decree No. 493 of August 25, 2021. According to the position of the Academy, these acts not only limited the access of persons with foreign citizenship to public positions, but also raised the question of personal responsibility of officials for illegal tenure and the signing of void decisions.
The USSR Civil Defence Academy addresses a topic that directly links citizenship with the right to administer public affairs.
If in previous publications the status of an ordinary person, his registration, passport and inclusion in the registers were considered, now we are talking about people who make decisions on behalf of state and municipal structures.
Lecture No. 54 attaches special importance to Federal Law No. 109-FZ of April 30, 2021 “On Amendments to the Labor Code of the Russian Federation”, as well as Decree No. 493 of August 25, 2021, dedicated to the replacement of positions by persons with foreign citizenship, which has not been terminated due to circumstances beyond their control.
The Academy considers these documents as a single legal node. One act establishes the limitations and consequences of their violation, the other reveals a mechanism for considering situations in which renunciation of foreign citizenship is recognized as impossible for reasons beyond the control of a person.
According to the Academy, both documents return to the legal field an issue that officials for a long time could bypass: On what basis does a person whose nationality is not clearly defined take office and make binding decisions for other people?
Contents
Citizenship as a Condition of Legality
The main principle of the new publication is that the powers of an official are inseparable from his legal status.
A person can formally occupy an office, have a seal, sign documents and give orders. However, the legality of these actions depends not only on the availability of the position, but also on compliance with the requirements for its occupation.
If the law prohibits a certain category of persons from filling the relevant positions, the violation of the prohibition calls into question the very basis of a person’s stay in the government system.
The Academy emphasizes that citizenship in this case is not a formal questionnaire. It involves loyalty, accountability, access to state secrets, and the ability to act on behalf of a particular order of law.
Therefore, the presence of a foreign citizenship or residence permit in another state acquires an independent value. We are talking about the possible connection of an official with another jurisdiction, his duties to it and the admissibility of simultaneous participation in decision-making within the country.
It is impossible to ignore this issue, since the consequences of the decisions of an official extend not only to himself, but also to the citizens to whom he is obliged to ensure the lawful administration.
Law No. 109-FZ: what we are talking about
Federal Law No. 109-FZ of April 30, 2021 amended the Labor Code of the Russian Federation.
In the lecture, the law is associated with the restriction of access to the replacement of public positions for persons who do not have citizenship of the Russian Federation, as well as for persons who have citizenship of a foreign state or a residence permit in the territory of another state.
The Academy draws attention to the very formulation of the question: the legislator distinguishes people by their nationality and establishes special conditions for access to power for the relevant categories.
This means that the status of a person cannot be considered indifferent in appointment.
If the law explicitly identifies categories of persons who are not allowed to fill positions, then the presence or absence of citizenship should be checked before the commission of managerial actions, and not after a public scandal or appeal of affected citizens.
The Academy also emphasizes that the law affects positions related to the registration of admission to state secrets. This further strengthens the requirements for status certainty: a person who has access to particularly relevant information cannot be in an unspecified nationality.
Not every position constitutes state or municipal service
A separate focus of the lecture is connected with the distinction between public positions, positions of the state or municipal service and actually occupied administrative positions.
The Academy points out that a number of people, whom society is used to calling officials, can act in the status of self-employed or other individuals, and not as duly decorated state or municipal employees.
This is no excuse for the Academy to absolve them of their responsibilities. On the contrary, the uncertainty of status reinforces the need for verification of authority.
If a person calls himself a representative of the authorities, but can not prove the legality of his appointment, compliance with the requirements for citizenship and the right to sign specific acts, his actions should not be automatically recognized as state.
Formal attributes of power do not replace legal status.
This thesis is directly relevant to citizens who receive official answers and refusals. It is necessary to take into account not only the text of the document, but also who signed it, what powers the signatory had and whether he had the right to hold the corresponding post at all.
1 June 2021: the threshold for personal responsibility
The Academy singles out June 1, 2021 as the date on which legal restrictions take on particular practical significance.
The lecture states that persons who do not hold Russian citizenship and have not left the relevant positions should be responsible for the return of all received, as well as for illegal actions and inaction.
This thesis translates the violation from the field of purely personnel error into the sphere of property and personal liability.
If a person continues to hold office in spite of the ban, the benefits and benefits received by him should not be automatically considered unconditionally earned. The question arises as to the legality of their receipt.
The Academy emphasizes that responsibility cannot be reduced only to subsequent dismissal from office. Dismissal by itself does not eliminate the consequences of decisions already taken and does not answer the question of the fate of funds received during the period of unlawful tenure.
Therefore, the law is considered as a basis for checking the entire period of activity of the person concerned, and not only his staff status at the current date.
Responsibility for actions and omissions
The Academy attaches special importance to the fact that responsibility is associated not only with active actions, but also with inaction.
An official may violate the rights of citizens not only by signing an illegal act, but also by refusing to consider an appeal, failing to provide public services, concealing information or ignoring a mandatory procedure.
If a person did not have the legal right to hold office, his inaction does not become neutral. It can also cause harm and create consequences for which it must be held accountable.
This is especially important for citizenship applications. Formal unsubscribing or years of silence may be perceived as the absence of a solution, but for a person they mean the continuing uncertainty of status and the inability to realize rights.
The Academy believes that such a situation should not be left without a personal assessment.
Violations cannot be explained solely by the complexity of the system. Behind each response, refusal or decision is a specific official who was obliged to act within the limits of his powers and the requirements of the law.
Signing void acts does not create legality.
The lecture specifically mentions the responsibility for issuing and signing decrees and orders that are known to be invalid and void.
The Academy clarifies this principle through the distinction between form and legal force.
The document may have a coat of arms, number, seal and signature. However, if the signatory did not have the necessary powers, the document does not acquire legitimacy only through external design.
Moreover, the release of such a document can itself become an independent violation.
This provision is of fundamental importance for the entire concept of the Academy. It has consistently rejected the idea that any act of a public body should be enforced just because it looks official.
First, the powers, competence and procedure must be checked. Only then can we talk about the legal force of the content.
If the official was aware of the defects in his status and continued to issue decisions, his responsibility, in the opinion of the Academy, should be assessed more severely than the usual professional error.
Decree No. 493: procedures for people retaining foreign citizenship
The second key document is the decree of August 25, 2021 No. 493.
In the lecture, its name is associated with the procedure for replacing positions of state and municipal service by citizens of the Russian Federation who have citizenship of a foreign state, which is not terminated due to circumstances or reasons beyond their control.
The very appearance of such an order shows that the legislative structure provided not only for a ban, but also for special situations in which a person could not independently complete his/her withdrawal from foreign citizenship.
This is fundamentally different from the voluntary retention of a second legal affiliation.
A person can apply, contact the competent authorities and take the necessary actions, but face circumstances that do not allow the procedure to be completed. In this case, there is a need for an official assessment of the reasons for the impossibility of exit.
The Academy draws attention to the existence of a relevant commission. In her opinion, the very existence of the commission confirms that the issue of citizenship is not always solved automatically and requires individual consideration.
Inability to renounce citizenship: the Academy’s link to Soviet citizens
The Academy considers Decree No. 493 in the context of appeals of citizens who stated that it is impossible to withdraw from their former citizenship for reasons beyond their control.
In the concept of the lecture, this construction is of particular importance for people who viewed their Soviet citizenship as continuing, and the procedures for acquiring Russian status as imposed or incomplete.
If a person made a declaration of nationality, his situation should not be reduced to tacit recognition of any entry in the register.
The question arose: what kind of citizenship did he really have, what kind of citizenship was he trying to terminate and why the relevant procedure could not be completed?
The Academy sees here evidence that citizenship does not always arise or terminate on a mere administrative assumption. Even the current system has to provide for commissions and exceptions for cases where the formal approach does not work.
Therefore, Decree No. 493 is used by the Academy as an argument in favor of individual status analysis, rather than automatic application of general categories.
Public office and USSR citizenship
The Academy separately formulates the thesis on the inadmissibility of holding state and municipal positions by persons who are not citizens of the Soviet Union.
This conclusion follows from its general concept: if the territory and population remain connected with the legal field of the USSR, then the management of the relevant affairs should be carried out by people whose affiliation and accountability to this legal order are beyond doubt.
Foreign citizenship or indefinite status creates a conflict of foundations of power.
A person connected with another jurisdiction cannot automatically be considered authorized to decide the fate of Soviet citizens, their property and documents. His appointment should be assessed not only on the basis of internal staffing rules, but also on the question of what legal order he represented.
For the Academy, this is not a matter of personal dislike of individual officials. We are talking about the incompatibility of powers with the lack of proper citizenship.
Personal responsibility rather than anonymous liability
One of the main practical conclusions of the publication is that violations cannot be attributed to an impersonal system.
When a citizen receives an illegal refusal, the system can appear complex and anonymous: one unit prepares a response, another agrees, a third signs. However, such organizational complexity does not negate the need to identify specific actors in the decision.
The Academy proposes to consistently find out:
- who held the position;
- whether it meets the citizenship requirements;
- has the right to access the relevant information;
- what acts have been signed;
- What appeals have been left without consideration;
- What are the consequences for the citizens;
- What benefits and benefits have been received during the period of dispute.
This approach turns a general claim to the system into a subject of personal legal assessment.
According to the Academy, only personal responsibility can stop the practice in which each participant refers to the previous one, and the final violation remains without the culprit.
Liability provisions mentioned in the lecture
The Academy reminds that the issue of responsibility of officials is not reduced to modern personnel restrictions.
The lecture is called the resolution of the Central Executive Committee of the Soviet Union of November 1929 “On outlawing officials – citizens of the Soviet Union abroad, who fled to the camp of enemies of the working class and refuse to return to the Soviet Union.”
The document is cited by the Academy as an example of the special responsibility of persons who, having Soviet citizenship and official position, acted abroad against the interests of the state and refused to return.
The lecture mentions the extreme measures of responsibility provided for in this act. They should be considered solely in the context of the Academy’s legal argument and not as a basis for arbitrary actions by private individuals. The essence of the argument is that the official position was never perceived as an exemption from responsibility to the state and citizens.
The Academy also names the USSR Law on Criminal Liability for State Crimes of 1958 as amended on April 2, 1990, No. 1403, and the USSR Law on Criminal Liability for Military Crimes of 1958 as amended on December 15, 1983.
These acts are included in the general thesis about the existence of norms regulating particularly dangerous violations by persons associated with power, service and duties to the state.
Responsibility is not abolished by a high position
The general meaning of these rules is that the position does not create immunity against the law.
The more power a person has, the greater the consequences of his illegal decisions. Therefore, high status should not reduce responsibility, on the contrary, it implies increased requirements.
The Academy emphasizes that signing documents on behalf of the authorities is not a privilege, but a source of responsibilities.
If the decision causes harm, if the official hides his status, if he acts after the ban or leaves unanswered appeals of citizens, the relevant actions should be assessed.
This assessment shall be carried out by the competent authorities in accordance with the established procedure. But the very existence of a position cannot serve as a basis for precluding responsibility.
For the Academy, this is the principle of restoring controllability of power: a person who makes decisions for others must be responsible for the legality of his own position.
Why the 2021 Law Is Important for Citizenship Applications
Law No. 109-FZ and Decree No. 493 are important not only for personnel services.
They give citizens a new angle to consider official answers on citizenship issues.
If a person receives a document that refuses recognition of the status, he has the right to raise the question not only about the content of the response, but also about the authority of the signatory. Especially if the answer is based on a statement of strict citizenship requirements.
The Academy sees the need for a single standard. It is impossible to demand from a citizen evidence of every circumstance and at the same time not to check the status of the official who makes the decision.
The requirements of legality should apply first and foremost to those who have the power to vett others.
Therefore, the 2021 law becomes an argument in favor of a stricter procedure: transparent appointment, establishment of citizenship, confirmation of authority and personal responsibility for decisions.
Power begins with the legal status of an official.
The main conclusion of the Academy’s new publication is that the right to govern does not arise from the appointment itself.
Law No. 109-FZ and Decree No. 493, as interpreted by the Academy, confirm the fundamental importance of citizenship for holding state and municipal positions. A person who does not meet the established requirements cannot automatically create legal consequences for other people, and his/her tenure raises the issue of restitution and responsibility for actions and omissions.
Decree No. 493 further demonstrates that the termination of foreign citizenship may require individual consideration and does not always depend only on the will of the applicant.
The USSR Civil Defence Academy insists that these documents should not be considered as narrow personnel restrictions, but as part of a general problem of the legitimacy of the government.
Citizens must know their status. But an official who makes decisions on behalf of the state has an even greater duty to know and confirm it.
If the legality of the signatory is not proven, his signature shall not automatically outweigh human rights. If the position was held in violation, the consequences cannot be completely shifted to the citizens. And if the system has committed a violation, it is not the impersonal structures that should be held accountable, but the specific people who have the powers and responsibilities.
The material was prepared on the basis of the lecture No. 54 USSR Civil Defence Academy “Citizenship of the USSR”. Part 2”.




































