Passport and power: we examine who controls shared assets, where public authority ends and how citizens can hold those who govern accountable.
Contents
Passport and power: the source of authority
An individual provides a collective organisation with property and the resources it needs to operate, only to become a petitioner before the apparatus that has been created. The central dispute about government lies between those two positions. Who determines the terms of the relationship: the people, from whom authority and shared resources originate, or the structure entrusted with administering them? The answer determines the meaning of citizenship, public services and people’s participation in the income generated by their common wealth.
The starting point is the origin of the property. A newly established organisation initially has no accumulated capital of its own. That capital comes from contributions made by its founders and members. In the analogy applied here to the organisation of the state, those members are the people. They create the material foundation for collective activity and choose its managers. The authority to govern is therefore connected to the terms on which property and the corresponding powers are placed under management.
A contract defines that relationship. It should establish the terms of cooperation, the participants’ rights and the powers of the appointed manager. Both the organisation’s general rules and the individual’s own position in relation to it matter. In delegating management powers, a participant expects certain duties to be fulfilled. Framing the issue this way makes it possible to discuss authority in terms of the task entrusted to it and its accountability to those who made its work possible.
Article 3 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation identifies the people as the bearer of sovereignty and the source of power. Article 9(1) enters the discussion through its treatment of land and natural resources as the basis of life. These provisions connect the political and material dimensions of the issue. If the people are the source of authority and resources sustain their lives, it is necessary to establish how administration gives practical effect to that position in economic activity and the distribution of its results.
A state organisation may engage in commercial activity. Yet the origin of the resources used for that activity remains relevant after income has been earned. Since the participants provided the assets and opportunities, profits should be distributed in their interests. This is a proposed arrangement of relationships: using common wealth should benefit those to whom the rights over it belong. An apparatus that sustains an independent existence at the expense of those resources alters the original purpose of management.
Who manages the common wealth?
Selling natural resources raises a more specific question: on what basis does a manager dispose of property? In the contractual model, both permission to undertake that activity and terms governing the individual’s share of the income are required. The profit, or part of it, should accrue to the participant; subsequent decisions about its use rest with that person. These terms define the relationship between those who own the resources and those allowed to use them.
We examine the corporate model of the Russian Federation through its institutions: administrations, agencies, ministries, courts and banks. These are presented as legal entities with their own registration records and directors. Each component of this system has a distinct organisational form. Its outward resemblance to a state apparatus therefore leaves a question about the origin of its powers: which organisation does a director represent, and under what rules does it operate?
We associate external registration with an international registry in Delaware, in the United States of America (USA), and domestic registration with the national register of legal entities. We infer from this relationship that the organisation is subject to the registering authority’s rules. The question posed from our Soviet perspective is how those registration arrangements relate to the people’s rights within their own territory. Recording an organisation and establishing the source of state sovereignty become separate subjects of inquiry.
A legal entity has a director whom its founding documents authorise to act on its behalf. This helps distinguish the organisation from the person performing a particular role. A representative acts within the relevant powers, while the property and obligations belong to the organisation itself. The same distinction is then applied to relations with a citizen: whom does the system recognise in the person approaching it, and whose interests does that person represent?
The passport becomes central to this transition. We interpret obtaining one as registration within a trading-company system, through which a person assumes the role of representative of a newly created legal entity. We associate a surname, given name and patronymic written in capital letters with the name of that registered organisation. A dispute over a document thus becomes a dispute over the individual’s position: a participant holding original rights is represented through a separate registration form.
Citizenship and accountability in government
Within this construction, the nature of the relationship with the administration changes. The individual requests services on the organisation’s terms and accepts the associated obligations. Meanwhile, the person’s original position as an owner of resources recedes behind membership of the registration system. The Soviet claim seeks to preserve the underlying question: how does the provision of services relate to individual rights, and who determined the terms on which the person was incorporated into the organisation?
To explore that question, the article distinguishes between an owner, a holder and an authorised representative. Property belongs to the owner; a holder uses an asset or opportunity made available to them; an authorised representative acts for the organisation. The distinction between these roles is what matters here. Being able to produce a document, use property or act on someone else’s behalf does not automatically establish who holds the underlying right or who determines the conditions for exercising it.
The representative is assigned obligations: payments, taxes, fines, dealings with institutions and participation in legal proceedings. The question of status therefore affects everyday life. A person needs to understand the capacity in which they are expected to act and the rights associated with that position. The dispute concerns the difference between an individual as the bearer of personal rights and the role through which an organisation records that individual.
The same problem arises in relation to citizenship. In the sequence described in our analysis, obtaining a new document is not accompanied by procedures for relinquishing Soviet citizenship and acquiring another citizenship. Citizenship and the form of registration are therefore treated separately. The Soviet side maintains the question of the individual’s membership of its state, even where everyday dealings with institutions take place through documents issued by a different administrative system.
The contractual model calls for clarity to be restored to these relationships. Who supplied the property? Who received the authority to manage it? What obligations were undertaken towards the participant? How is that participant’s share of the results determined? These questions connect an individual document to the organisation as a whole. They allow government to be discussed in terms of powers, accountability and the interests of the individual who provides its material foundation.
The citizen’s position consequently has significance beyond a registration entry. It connects sovereignty, shared resources and participation in the life of one’s state. The Soviet approach requires that connection to be preserved in any discussion of economic management and public services. Administration derives its purpose from people’s rights and interests. It is to those people that the meaning of decisions, the use of property and the distribution of the results of collective activity must be explained.
Document for comparison: Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Articles 15, 17 and 21. These provisions on nationality, property and participation in government offer a point of comparison with our model.
More articles on history and law: USSR Civil Defence Academy. USSR stands for the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.






































